Saturday, February 19, 2011

What if George Washington Had Never Been Born?

What if George Washington had never been born? What if the "father of our country" was someone else? Would the French and Indian War have started? Would the Continental Army have defeated the British under someone else's leadership? Would someone else have successfully thwarted a military coup at Newburgh? Would a different general refused opportunities and requests for supreme authority? Would the Constitutional Convention been successful without his authoritative presence? And who would have been the first President of the United States?

George Washington and the French and Indian War

Would the American Revolution have taken place, absent the French and Indian War? Most historians would probably say "no," as the French and Indian War (aka "Seven Years' War") accelerated the cultural and political divide between the colonies and the Mother Country. Without the French and Indian War, Britain's treasury would've been in a much healthier position in the 1760s. Thus, it's unlikely Britain would've felt compelled to levy as many taxes on the colonies or station troops in North America.

Since George Washington was right in the thick of instigating the French and Indian War, it's tempting to conclude that the Seven Years' War might never have occurred. Thus, some might wonder if Washington was at least indirectly responsible for the Revolutionary War happening in the first place.

While the young, eager, and inexperienced Washington did indeed stumble his way into a skirmish that led to the French and Indian War, the nature in which that skirmish took place and the way in which tensions were already mounting between France and England leads one to believe that the French and Indian War was inevitable. It's going much too far to conclude that Washington was solely responsible for starting the war or that the war never would've happened without him. In the case of the French and Indian War, George Washington rode events more than he drove them.

George Washington and the American Revolution

As with the French and Indian War, George Washington was incidental to the American Revolution starting. Sure, he helped fuel tensions against the Mother Country from his estate in Virginia and seat in the House of Burgesses. Sure, he co-wrote The Fairfax Resolves. Sure, he was part of the First and (initially) the Second Continental Congress. But, as with the French and Indian War, he rode events more than driving them. The American Revolution would've happened, even if George Washington had never been born.

That's not to say, however, that the American Revolution would've been a victory for the Americans, had Washington not played his part in it. Yes, the Revolutionary War would've happened, but once it broke out, strong leadership was needed to see it through to a successful conclusion. And it's difficult to imagine who else could've provided that leadership other than George Washington.

Had Washington not been alive, the Continental Congress would've had to consider the likes of Artemas Ward (health issues), Israel Putnam (age and health concerns, a stroke in 1779 ended his career), Charles Lee (issues with competence, character, and loyalty), John Hancock (an impressive signature and trader, but an effective general only in his imagination), or Horatio Gates (an ambitious, conniving opportunist who showed his true colors at Camden). Their best choices would likely have been Philip Schuyler or Richard Montgomery, but neither of these men were optimal choices. Some of my readers may be thinking Benedict Arnold (who, aside from the whole treason thing, was an excellent leader), Nathanael Greene, or Henry Knox, but these men flourished under Washington's guidance and mentoring. The scenario we're considering is 1775, not later in the war, when either Knox or Greene would've been an able replacement to Washington.

Even though Washington's generalship in the Revolutionary War produced mixed results, he excelled in the areas that mattered most. His character was unimpeachable, thus he could be trusted with the army and the authority given him. He was brave, thus earning the just respect of his men and inspiring them to similar acts of courage. He was a superb strategist, in that he quickly grasped the nature of the "long game" and the need to keep his army in the field and not risk it in too many grandiose, stand-up engagements. He knew when he had to have a victory, such as a Trenton, and when to cut his losses, such as Germantown.

It's very difficult to imagine any other person leading the Continental Army to victory over the British Empire in the American Revolution.

George Washington and the Revolution's Aftermath

Washington's indispensable nature becomes truly evident in the closing years and immediate aftermath of the Revolutionary War. After Yorktown, what little public sentiment there was to support the war effort began to quickly evaporate, leaving Washington's army in the field with poor supplies, inadequate pay, and broken promises. Washington didn't dare support the dissolution of his forces, because that would remove any pressure on the British to grant American independence in the peace negotiations he knew were taking place in France. Washington therefore had the dangerous and unenviable task of keeping an increasingly frustrated, desperate, and disillusioned army in the field.

Washington knew when to be harsh in his discipline and when to make concessions. And he knew when to risk his own reputation and possible safety. His performance at Newburgh is the stuff of legend. Can anyone possibly imagine someone else other than George Washington pulling that off?

What's more, when Washington was essentially offered the keys to the government and the ability to become a dictator, he refused. Would Horatio Gates have refused? Would Charles Lee have refused?

Without Washington's character, fortitude, and calming presence, the American Revolution would likely have degenerated into civil unrest and a military dictatorship. The dream of freedom and a republican form of government would've been stillborn.

George Washington and the Constitutional Convention

In terms of the actual content of the Constitution, Washington's participation at the Constitutional Convention was more symbolic than substantive. The members of the Convention understood Washington would likely be the first Chief Executive, so the way they hammered out the executive branch of government was likely influenced by this realization. In terms of actual discussion and debate, Washington said very little. It is certainly conceivable, though, that the Constitution would've been very close in content and composition to what it was, had Washington not been present.

Ratification of the new Constitution or the very fact that the Convention happened in the first place are different matters altogether. Washington was instrumental in laying the groundwork for Americans understanding that a stronger government, than the one provided for the Articles of Confederation, was necessary. And his attendance at the Constitutional Convention did much to allay fears and concerns that a monarchy or dictatorship was being erected in Philadelphia.

After the Constitution was signed, Washington lent his name and prestige to support ratification of the document. It's unlikely the Constitution would've been ratified, had Washington been absent from the Convention or had he declined to support it.

George Washington and the First Presidency

Ask the average American what George Washington did as President and you will get a smattering of answers, most of them sparse. There is the impression that George Washington was more a figurehead than a substantive leader, and that his contributions as President were minimal. Nothing could be further from the truth.

President Washington created the Cabinet, appointed the first Supreme Court, presided over the adoption of the Bill of Rights, kept us out of a renewed (and costly) war with Great Britain, put down the Whiskey Rebellion, and supported the economic policies of Alexander Hamilton which were necessary to get the United States on a sound financial footing. He also supported moving the capital of the nation to its present location, and took an active part in its initial designs. Most historians rank Washington as at least our second or third greatest President, falling behind only Abraham Lincoln and sometimes Franklin D. Roosevelt.

Washington was Indispensable

When you consider all that George Washington did for the United States -- and didn't do (such as becoming dictator or king) -- one has to agree with the late Washington biographer James Thomas Flexner, who wrote that George Washington was "the indispensable man."

Remove George Washington from history and you remove quite possibly the very existence of the United States of America and most certainly its nature and identity as the world's leading superpower and the greatest republic the world has ever known.

******

For more on George Washington, check on the latest biography Washington: A Life by Ron Chernow.

96 comments:

JMS said...

The ultimate significance of George Washington's life lies in the fact that he single-handedly redefined our traditional idea of greatness. Before he lived, to be great was to be triumphant: to conquer an enemy's territory, to kill his soldiers, and subdue his populace. In an age when divine right held sway over most of the planet, greatness was measured by the authority vested in one man, and the lengths to which he would go to keep that authority.

No act was perhaps as symbolic of Washington's fabled "disinterested" virtue than the surrender of his sword to Congress shortly following the official cessation of the Revolutionary War in December of 1783. Historian Gordon Wood related the magnitude of such observance of duty: "It was extraordinary; a victorious general's surrendering his arms and returning to his farm was unprecedented in modern times. Cromwell, William of Orange, Marlborough--all had sought political rewards commensurate with their military achievements."

What struck me about Wood's analysis of the nation's first leader was the particular way in which Washington's character affected the above-mentioned mystique of his decisions and actions. As Wood put it, "Washington's genius, Washington's greatness, lay in his character."
To his everlasting credit, George Washington was ambiguous about power. The man who could have been king insisted that ultimate sovereignty lay with the people, however imperfect their judgment. At the end of the war, and again at the end of his presidency, he calmly walked away from power. This genius for renunciation prompted the dying Napoleon in his windswept exile to remark, "They wanted me to be another Washington."
http://www.archives.gov/publications/prologue/1994/spring/george-washington-4.html

parking said...

america really has a lot of historical stories, and has a very unique culture, somehow when I can visit to America ...???

MPA said...

I think you guys are swinging to hard from George's gonads.

Augusta said...

To the person above, George Washington did not invent the surrender of power after he had his 15 minutes. That was a Roman ideal of greatness many centuries before Washington was born. Washington, like other educated men, sought to emulate the ancient Romans.

Certainly things might have turned out differently without Washington, but we can't assume all other things would then be constant. It's easy to imagine life without something but not the multitude of ways it could be different :)

That said, I'm glad I found this blog. Very refreshing!

Anonymous said...

Cincinnatus set the example of the general returning to his plow. They named a city after him in Ohio. I wonder if Washington's ambivalence towards power wasn't inspired by feelings of guilt at having precipitated so much bloodshed with the assassination of Joseph Coulon de Jumonville. William Thackeray said of Washington:
“It was strange that in a savage forest of Pennsylvania, a young Virginian officer should fire a shot, and waken a war which was to last for 60 years, which was to cover his own country and pass into Europe, to cost France her American colonies, to sever ours from us, and create the great western republic; to rage over the old world when extinguished in the new; and, of all the myriad engaged in the vast contest, to leave the prize of the greatest fame to him who struck the first blow.”
Sixty years later the world was a very different place. Austria was modelling itself on the French Empire and Prussian militancy was firmly established and set to cast its shadow over the next hundred years. A shadow which led inexorably to the dictatorships of fascism and communism.

Jim Rada said...

You make some great observations. Maybe you should consider writing an alternate history novel based on this blog.

You definitely show Washington's impact on our culture.

kavin paker said...

free genealogy websites that offer transcriptions of records, and websites from state archives. bubblegum casting

James Rada said...

I saw something the other day that said Dinesh DeSouza (sp?) had made a new movie based on the premise "What if George Washington had died in battle?" Don't know anything else about it, but it would be interesting to see if it reaches similar conclusions as your post.

jack said...

You make some great observations. Maybe you should consider writing an alternate history novel based on this blog. bubblegum casting

jack said...

Joe Menkevich, researcher in history has published a new paper on the Lydia Darragh legend. You can read it here. Boca CPA

jack said...

Very well said, Jodie. Telling a compelling story draws the reader past imperfection. Great advice.seo barcelona

jack said...

he Americans as best she could. The details of Darragh's activities are difficult to pin down, as the main source of information is Ann Darragh, Lydia's daughter, who told the stories years after the events. Unfortunately, some of Ann's accounts don't jibe with other records from the Revolutionary War period, calling many of them into question. Mannheim Innenstadt hotel

jack said...

Again you combine knowledge in a kinda factual way with personal tweaks here and there that liven things up. watchthisfree.com/

jack said...

26free genealogy websites that offer transcriptions of records, and websites from state archives Coffee Grinder Reviews

jack said...

Austria was modelling itself on the French Empire and Prussian militancy was firmly established and set to cast its shadow over the next hundred years Ian Filippini Santa Barbara

jack said...

I just sent the story to a friend who is leaving for Afghanistan soon. And thanks for the heads up on the grossness of Michael Seo Service

jack said...

the person above, George Washington did not invent the surrender of power after he had his 15 minutes. high PR backlinks

jack said...

I am constantly reminded that we are lucky to have these opportunities, and we must not take that for granted high PR backlinks

jack said...

saw something the other day that said Dinesh DeSouza (sp?) had made a new movie based on the premise "What if George Washington had died in battle seo in barcelona

jack said...

Our reading, talking and listening told us that we would not be disappointed, and we have been very happy with our purchase. Sofia agrees. High PR Backlinks

jack said...

To the person above, George Washington did not invent the surrender of power after he had his 15 minutes. That was a Roman ideal of greatness many centuries before Washington was born. Washington, like other educated men, sought to emulate the ancient Romans. virgin mobile contact

jack said...

I just sent the story to a friend who is leaving for Afghanistan soon. And thanks for the heads up on the grossness of Michael t mobile helpline

jack said...

To the person above, George Washington did not invent the surrender of power after he had his 15 minutes. sky contact number

jack said...

It should be noted that whilst ordering papers for sale at paper writing service,
you can get unkind attitude. In case you feel that the bureau is trying to cheat samsung helpline

jack said...

Most of the time I don't make comments on websites, but I'd like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post. bt openreach contact number

jack said...

To those of you who posted that the post wasn't that helpful, I have updated it (as of February 19, 2011). Hopefully, you'll find the new post better. Thanks! npower

jack said...

I am pretty much happy with the contents you've got mentioned. I wished to thanks for this nice post. I enjoyed each little a part of it and that i are anticipating the new updates.wine refrigerator reviews

jack said...

It's more important now than ever. Especially in this digital age where we expect news and information fast. natwest number

jack said...

It's more important now than ever. Especially in this digital age where we expect news and information fast. hmrc contact number

jack said...

Thanks so much for sharing your useful information. I just started in this and I am getting to know it better! Cheers, keep up the good work esa phone number

jack said...

It's more important now than ever. Especially in this digital age where we expect news and information fast. I recently read the first pages of ebay customer service

jack said...

La salud sexual y reproductiva de los y las adolescentes es motivo de preocupación de diferentes organismos de salud nacional e internacional. dla

jack said...

A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. i see you got really very useful topics , i will be always checking your blog thanks. High PR backlinks

jack said...

Surprising that Los Angeles is so close to Detroit in this measure. What a sad statement for Southern California. seo services barcelona

jack said...

Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article high PR Backlinks

jack said...

I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on a number of the subjects you write concerning here. Again, awesome seo in barcelona

jack said...

I really appreciate that you submitted this nowadays and assisted me very much with this details. Keep going like this, my man high pr links

jack said...

The info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks very much for this great article. This is a great inspiring article high pr links

jack said...

definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Top Ten Ranking

jack said...

It's absolutely amazing and I definitely recommend this. The fasteners on the loop necklace thing had to be duct taped to stay togethe Weight loss. cheap backlinks

jack said...

Is there a place on tj´his or any other website that can translate C√©line´french song to english, and I mean the right way. It is not always that they have the same meaning i english a french, that´s why i want the direct transfer. seo service in barcelona

jack said...

I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this page on my blog. American Taxes system

jack said...

I mean the right way. It is not always that they have the same meaning i english a french, that´s why i want the direct transfer weight loss tips

jack said...

Your style is unique compared to other people I have read stuff from.I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I'll just book mark this site sky phone number

jack said...

The figures for New Hampshire surprise me as there was a decent mix of white and African Americans on campus when I studied at Keene State best backlinks

jack said...

I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on a number of the subjects you write concerning here. Again, awesome buy backlinks

jack said...

It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. Internet Marketing Conference

jack said...

And improved, quality data can be used to demonstrate the need for postabortion care programs and advocate for funding SEO Conference

jack said...

And improved, quality data can be used to demonstrate the need for postabortion care programs and advocate for funding SEO Conference

jack said...

it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide. IM Conference

jack said...

I carry been seeking data for this point for the yesterday a lot of hours Also establish ones announce to help possibly be effectively Internet Marketing Conference

jack said...

Austria was modelling itself on the French Empire and Prussian militancy was firmly established and set to cast its shadow over the next hundred years Anonymous Mailbox

jack said...

I really appreciate that you submitted this nowadays and assisted me very much with this details. Keep going like this, my man.high pr blog comments

jack said...

I used to work in electroplating they sometimes encouraged us to write, but I could never come up with something as well written as that SEO copmpanies

jack said...

This was a really great contest and hopefully I can attend the next one. It was alot of fun and I really enjoyed myself. seo barcelona

jack said...

I do think you should consider a little more about individual previous to composing about it. good backlinks

jack said...

That was a Roman ideal of greatness many centuries before Washington was born. Washington, like other educated men, sought to emulate the ancient Romans. good backlinks

jack said...

I’m a little lost on everything. Would you suggest starting with a freevine vera reviews

jack said...

i agree with this comment pron movies leave bad impact on young generation. SEO

jack said...

I am writing a paper of the qualities of a great leader and george washington in particular. it gave me a general understandingwedding venues

jack said...

I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good workwedding venues manchester

jack said...

Thanks for sharing nice information . i like your post and all you share with us is uptodate and quite informative, Seo services boca

jack said...

It is easy to see that you are passionate about your writing. If only I had your writing ability I look forward to more updates safety guidelines newyork

jack said...

I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work watch onepiece online

jack said...


There is no reason why a plumber can’t lead the way and set the example. The electric motor is two to five times more efficient than a diesel engine Seo in Boca raton

jack said...

I was exactly searching for. Great work.Thanks for such post and please keep it up. tips for losing weight

jack said...

it has been months for me. Nicely this article that i've been waited for so long.barcelona seo services

jack said...

It consists of wonderful and useful posts. I've read many of them and also got so much from them seo barcelona

jack said...

I have never visited any site about mad ud af huset like this. I would like to bookmark this link and share to all my friend as well http://phonesheriffapp.com

jack said...

I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. Very likely I’m going to bookmark your blog . seo barcelona

jack said...

I ever have in a season for GS. I think you would be hard pressed to find somebody with the same consistency seo in barcelona

jack said...

i am from this post the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us. seo barcelona

jack said...

i am from this post the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us. seo barcelona

jack said...

Unfortunately, some of Ann's accounts don't jibe with other records from the Revolutionary War period. six degree flow

jack said...

The very software is normally highly consumer-helpful plus simple and easy in order to implement best online brokerage

jack said...

I recently read the first pages of "Of Mice and Men best online brokerage

jack said...

I found so many exciting aspects in your weblog site web page website web page website, especially its discussion comparaison mutuelle

jack said...

You make some great observations. Maybe you should consider writing an alternate history novel based on this blog. Ungagged

jack said...

You make some great observations. Maybe you should consider writing an alternate history novel based on this blog. Ungagged

jack said...

I am writing a paper of the qualities of a great leader and george washington in particular. IM Conference

jack said...

I care about what I said just now scale of civilization - how are you this big treat your weakness and minority. money lender

jack said...

I would like to bookmark this link and share to all my friend as well seo in spain

jack said...

I am hopeful the same best work from you as well. Actually your creative writing abilities has motivated me boca raton seo

jack said...

It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues.Vegas Conference

jack said...

I'm still not enjoying it to its full potential. I'll have to sink some money into a good gaming rig, before I can enjoy the best of its graphicsUngagged

jack said...

Higher efficiency means less energy consumption. Less energy consumption means lower costs and less pollution Cheap and best seo

jack said...

hat was a Roman ideal of greatness many centuries before Washington was born. web design company miami

jack said...

I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work boca seo advance

jack said...

I strategy to create an content about copper robbery, and I want to know if you have knowledgeable this. boca movers

jack said...

I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. miami movers

jack said...

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post nice post, thanks for sharing. SEO in cheap

jack said...

I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work. seo barcelona

jack said...

I had been on the front lines of vaccine education and awareness, continually partnering with families to protect children. And out of nowhere, measles arrived. seo spain

jack said...

I don’t actually comment and don’t like to spend time in typing the comment. vine vera seo barcelona

jack said...

I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work. hack clash of clans

jack said...

It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog house movers boca